Быков о Честертоне

[avva]

Чрезвычайно неумный Быков пишет о Честертоне.

Право же, как будто ушат грязной пены вылил на любимого писателя. Честертону-то ладно, а мне обидно. Спаси нас Бог от такой хвалы.

olshansky уже цитировал кусок отсюда, и я уже высказал там своё мнение, но целиком всю статью прочитал только сейчас.

Омерзительное ощущение. Хочется Быкову линейкой по пальцам, с размаху.

Comments

[ingvar.livejournal.com]

1) È ÷òî, ýòî òèïà ñ÷èòàåòñÿ, ÷òî îí ïèñàë î ×åñòåðòîíå? Ïî-ìîåìó ïðîñòî òèïè÷íûé áåçñìûñëåííûé æóðíàëèñòñêèé ãîí.
2) "Âñå ïðî÷èå åãî ðîìàíû íà ôîíå «×åòâåðãà» ãëÿäÿòñÿ óæàñíî ïðèìèòèâíûìè è íàèâíûìè, äåòåêòèâíûå ðàññêàçû íàòÿíóòûìè, òðàêòàòû ñêó÷íûìè." Êîãäà æóðíàëèñò òàê ïèøåò, ýòî îáû÷íî çíà÷èò, ÷òî îí ñàìè ïðîèçâåäåíèÿ ( ïóñòü è íå â îðèãèíàëå) íå ÷èòàë. Íó ìîæåò áûòü íà ×åòâåðã åãî è õâàòèëî, à îñòàëüíîå îí âèäèìî çíàåò òîëüêî â îáúåìå ÷üèõ-íèáóäü êðèòè÷åñêèõ ñòàòåé. Òðàêòàòû, êñòàòè, èìõî, çàìå÷àòëüíûå. ×åãî ñòîèò òîëüêî "Åâàíãåëèå - ïåðâûé ïðèêëþ÷åí÷åñêèé ðîìàí"

Áûêîâ - äóðàê

[trurle.livejournal.com]

Àãà.
äåòåêòèâíûå ðàññêàçû /êàæóòñÿ - Ò./ íàòÿíóòûìè
Ãäå æå âñå-òàêè ïðÿ÷óò ëèñò?

Àíàòîëèé

[foma.livejournal.com]

ó ìåíÿ ê Âàì âîïðîñ áûë... íî âîò ñ ïî÷òà Âàøà íå ðàáîòàåò ïî÷åìó-òî âîçâðàò ïðèõîäèò.

Re: Àíàòîëèé

[avva.livejournal.com]

ß ïîëó÷èë ïèñüìî íà ñàìîì äåëå. Ïîñòàðàþñü âûÿñíèòü, ÿ âîîáùå-òî ïðî ýòî íè÷åãî íå çíàþ ïî÷òè, íî ïîïðîáóþ.

[favorov.livejournal.com]

Íî, ñ äðóãîé ñòîðîíû, ëèíåéêîé ïî ïàëüöàì - ñëàáûé àðãóìåíò ïðîòèâ îáâèíåíèé â òîòàëèòàðíîñòè ñîçíàíèÿ ëèáåðàëüíîé È.

Re:

[avva.livejournal.com]

Ôàêò. Íî, âî-ïåðâûõ, ê ëèáåðàëüíîé È. (â ïîíèìàíèè Áûêîâà ïî êðàéíåé ìåðå) ÿ íå îòíîøóñü, à âî-âòîðûõ, ýòî òàêîé ò¸ìíûé èìïóëüñ, êîòîðûé ïðèä¸òñÿ, óâû, ïîäàâèòü, êàê íàì, È., ñâîñéòâåííî.

ñïàñèáî áîëüøîå

[foma.livejournal.com]

à òî äóðàöêàÿ òàêàÿ ïðîáëåìà.

Re: ñïàñèáî áîëüøîå

[avva.livejournal.com]

Âîò ýòî íå ïîìîæåò Âàì?
http://www.livejournal.com/talkread.bml?itemid=15327554&thread=20075365#t20075365

Àíàòîëèé, áûòü ìîæåò, âû â êóðñå äåëà

[gleb.livejournal.com]

Ñîâåòñêèé òàíê ïîïàë â áîëîòî
åëîâàÿ ïðîãíóëàñü ãàòü,
åãî áîìáèëè ñ ñàìîëåòà,
åãî ôàøèñòñêàÿ ïåõîòà
ïîä âå÷åð ñòàëà îêðóæàòü...

- íå çíàêîìû ëè âàì ýòè ñòðî÷êè. Ñòðàøíî õî÷ó íàéòè òåêñò - ýòî ñòèõîòâîðåíèå ÿ âûó÷èë â ïÿòü ëåò è ÷èòàë íàèçóñòü...

Re: Àíàòîëèé, áûòü ìîæåò, âû â êóðñå äåëà

[avva.livejournal.com]

Óâû, íåçíàêîìû, õîòÿ çâó÷èò î÷åíü óâëåêàòåëüíî ;)

Re: Àíàòîëèé, áûòü ìîæåò, âû â êóðñå äåëà

[gleb.livejournal.com]

÷òî æ, êàê ãîâîðèë Ñåìåí Ñåìåíû÷ Ãîðáóíêîâ, äåáîøèð è ïüÿíèöà - áóäåì èñêàòü...

*sigh*

[sburn.livejournal.com]

Okay, either I'm hallucinating, all this is in a different language or.. or I'm hallucinating. Look at the pretty symbols! Aren't they funny!

Re: *sigh*

[quatermass.livejournal.com]

Nah, it's plain English, you're hallucinating, man :O)

Re: *sigh*

[sburn.livejournal.com]

I suspected as much. That's the last time I drink tap water...

they are kidding, man

[nine_k]

This was Russian. Cyrillic letters, you see.
Jewish letters were also spotted in some posts -- even funnier; these are right to left. Other languages must also be present.

Re: they are kidding, man

[sburn.livejournal.com]

They're kidding? Really? Wow! ;)

Seriously though, I'm half tempted to install foreign character sets just to satisfy my insane curiosity.

funny characters

[nine_k]

If you use reasonably recent M$ windows (which is highly probable), run 'Character map' app (charmap.exe; you may need to add it as a Windows component in 'Add programs') and see a lot of bizarre chars just by browsing through a decent unicode font, such as Arial or Tahoma.

Re: funny characters

[sburn.livejournal.com]

Or I could install the cyrillic character set into IE and then fail to read the posts for a completely different reason, namely that of not having the slightest clue about any foreign language that does not use the arabic alphabet. :)

I really need to educate myself I see...

Arabic alphabet?

[nine_k]

Man, I see you using Latin alphabet (maybe in Hertfordshire Arabic alphabet is used? though, it seems unlikely). Russian language uses Cyrillic alphabet, along with a few other European languages.
I cannot read Arabic, too. Have to educate myself, too :-)

[quatermass.livejournal.com]

Âîò ìóäèëî-òî. Íó ïðè ÷åì çäåñü, ñïðàøèâàåòñÿ, Ëîéîëà è êàêàÿ íàôèã êðîâü? Òèïè÷íûé ïîëóîîáðàçîâàííûé æóðíàëþãà - ñëûøàë çâîí, äà íå çíàåò ãäå îí. ×åñòåðòîíó áû îí íå ïîíðàâèëñÿ...